Reviews

Based on 14 reviews

Pam J

Great Italian food

This is actually a restaurant with a gluten free menu (even though we didn't eat gluten free.) The pesto penne and the pasta with mushrooms are delicious. They have a great wine list and the service was very friendly and helpful in...

posted at 05/02/10

Megan P

Great Italian food, nice atmosphere!

The food at Carelli's is consistently good and the staff is friendly and welcoming. The prices are a little steep, but worth it. Nice wine selection too!

posted at 02/20/10

Joette D

Try Carelli's

Don't be put off by the location of Carelli's. the restaurant has consistently excellent food and service and the winter time ambience (around a central fireplace) is top notch.

posted at 02/06/10

rj_citys

delicious pizza

We ordered a pizza for takeout. Flavor was really excellent; texture depends on your tastes - this one was a medium-thickness crust and lots of cheese. We dug it. Restaurant is very pretty.

posted at 07/18/06

new_in_town

Not impressed

This is a beautiful restaurant but the accolades stop there. One appetizer we purchased was the caprese salad. For ~$9 I expected a lot more. The presentation was not appetizing. The mozzerella and tomatoes were placed haphazardly on the rim of a large bowl with the salad containing limp leaves on the inside. The salad came with what someone might have thought a clever duo of balsamic and oil carafes on the side for the customer to poor. This should be done in the kitchen. The pasta dishes were fair but not outstanding. All in all I would not be back.

posted at 07/26/06

njr5353

The best Italian I have found in Boulder county!

My wife and I have been dining at Carelli's of Boulder for about the last six years, we discovered this small family owned restaraunt after relocating to Boulder. The staff is excellent and there is not a touch of "snootiness" that is typical of other restaraunts of this caliber. The location humble from the outside but an inviting patio leads to a remarkable interior that has two fireplacves which create an ambience that is unparalleled. Take a loved one here and I guarantee the staff will not let you down. I typically order the steak pizzaiola and my wife orders the shrimp scampi everytime! Definetely two thumbs up!

posted at 01/16/08

danod80

Great restaurant !!

Exceptional dining experience. Having been to most Boulder restaurants, Carelli's will not disappoint. Great ambience, indoor fireplace is a great idea. Will be back again soon!

posted at 02/06/08

pathfinder3

Awsome Dinner Experience

I Had the pleasure of eating at this jewel last week for graduation. I heared of Carelli's but never went there because I live in Denver. However now it's on my radar for sure.The encrusted Yellowfin Tuna was delightful and my wifes Veal Shank was very tasty. They really know how to do risotto right too! My waiter didn't know the characteristics of one of the wines we quized him on but besides that he did a great job. Highly recommend this diamond.

posted at 05/27/08

Boulderite12

Ambience nice not service

Elegant and classy atmosphere, yet when it came to service and my taste buds, Carelli's left a lot to be desired. WIth the price of an entree, I expected better food and more attention. I don't think I will be back anytime soon.

posted at 07/08/08

LizWhite2

Excellent Pizza, Good Service!

Carelli's has really good food, a nice atmosphere and decent service (they should train the high school kids better in table service). We like the pizza and salads and the pasta has always been good too. We're vegetarians so we can't comment on the meat dishes, everything we have tried has been excellent!

posted at 07/19/08

bufforlife

I wouldn't know what it tastes like

I wish I could write about the food or ambiance of this place, but I cannot, since the manager has not called back to answer a question.

I got some gift certificates that expired after one year. First question, why issue and take people's money, if that money is no good after one year. Second problem, tried to call the manager but he was not in at 8:30 pm, I don't where a manager would be at 8:30 during dinner, but he was not there. Left a message to get a call back in regards to the "expired" (someone paid good money for that gift) gift certificates and 10 days later, I still have not gotten a call back. I would assume the food and place must be OK, based on the other reviews, but, I would not be able to tell. So far customer service gets and F.

But back to the "gift" certificates. Why issue them with an expiration date. I got pretty sick in that year and did not want food and now someone's hard earned dollars will be in the recycle bin, because they do not accept them. I just do not understand.

posted at 08/09/08

goodest

relaxing comfortable yet sophisticated

My wife and I ate at Carelli's the other night and again were more than pleased.
The new addition to the bar makes for a wonderful place to have drinks and
casual dining while on the other side of the open fire place the dining room
was busy yet still comfortable and made for a relaxing dining experience.
Try the eggplant parm, very good.

posted at 10/09/08

DarrenWilson

Nice atmosphere

This place has been here for a long time but I had never tried it out until my parents came into town for the holidays. Very nice. Good service, great food.

posted at 12/27/08

Like the Boss

Owner is Awesome and Always Attentive

I have been a long time fan of Carelli's . Even if they have an "off" day with their food the ambiance is great and the owner is always there to make things right! Give it a try...and don't forget to have a Limoncello...or two!

posted at 03/05/10

Review This Business

Carellis of Boulder

Contact us

Location

Reviews

Pam J

Megan P

Joette D

rj_citys

new_in_town

njr5353

danod80

pathfinder3

Boulderite12

LizWhite2

bufforlife

goodest

DarrenWilson

Like the Boss

Detail information

Nearby

Jalinos Pizza

Mad Mushroom Pizza

Cosmos Pizza

The Sink

Mamacitas

Teresa's Pizza Colore

Abos Pizza

Abo's Pizza On The Hill

Carellis of Boulder